Evidence of undercover Russian troops in Ukraine debunked

April 22, 2014 — 14 Comments

Evidence shows that photographic evidence is being misused to “prove” the presence of Russian special forces in Eastern Ukraine. It is clear that corporate media are complicit, either through stupidity or design, in this attempt to mould perceptions of the situation in post-coup Ukraine.

The photos in question have been used widely in corporate media including by NBC and the BBC:

_74361105_f13537c6-7e52-4339-8c7c-7138c41de8ff

According to a CNN report:

“Ukraine provided the photos to those observers from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, according to the briefing dossier obtained by CNN’s Elise Labott.”

“One image shows a gunman with a long beard during an assault on a police station in Kramatorsk who appears similar to a Russian special forces member photographed during the Russian invasion of Georgia.”

“Another shows gunmen photographed occupying administrative buildings in Slaviansk who appear similar to men pictured in what Ukrainian officials described as a “family photo” of a Russian sabotage and reconnaissance unit.”

With the use of Tineye it was possible to locate another version of the supposed “family photo” of “the sabotage reconnaissance group of the Chief Intelligence Directorate of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces“(centre bottom in collage above) and some checking around the web eventually turned up the original photograph – which was uploaded to Instagram by photographer Maxim Dondyuk 10 days ago, tagged with the name of the town #Slavyansk:

#vscocam #ukraine #donbass #slavyansk

A photo posted by Maxim Dondyuk (@maximdondyuk) on

According to Maxim Dondyuk’s news page the photo has even been used in Russian Reporter magazine and in Paris Match where it is clearly marked as having been taken in Slavyansk.

It is also worth pointing out that Slavyansk and Kramatorsk are just 8.5 miles or 17 minutes apart by road.

The BBC quoted US State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki as saying there was “broad unity in the international community about the connection between Russia and some of the armed militants in eastern Ukraine” and “The photos presented by the Ukrainians last week only further confirm this.”

It is also worth mentioning that the photos which the BBC says “purport to show the same Russian soldier (circled) in operations in Georgia in 2008 and Kramatorsk and Sloviansk in Ukraine in 2014″ show a man with a reddish beard in Georgia in 2008 (centre, bottom below):

Ukrainegeorgia man with beard

Whilst the man in Slavyansk/Kramatorsk has a grey/black beard – as is even clearer from this picture uploaded to instagram by Maxim Bondyuk earlier today:

Thanks to Lucas from the comments below (Update 25/04) here is a higher resolution version of the photo man with the red beard – which deminstartes he is clearly not the man in East Ukraine:

georgia

It is impossible to rule out the possibility special forces of various countries are present in Eastern Ukraine (the Russians were after all present in Crimea to create the conditions for a referendum as Vladimir Putin has admitted).

What is in question here is the tendency of the Western corporate media to unquestioningly pass on propaganda they receive via the US State Department, (even days after John Kerry was caught presenting fake anti-semitic leaflets as genuine), whilst simultaneously ignoring the clear evidence of a far right, fascist-influenced and Russophobe elite having seized power in most of the country:

Svoboda leader
Photo of Svoboda leader Oleh Tyahnybok by Graham W Phillips ‏@GrahamWP_UK (Svoboda controls a number of ministries in the interim government.)

Update 23/04/2014

The New York Times which also passed on the State Department propaganda to its readers, today published a retraction with the additional information that:

A packet of American briefing materials that was prepared for the Geneva meeting asserts that the photograph was taken in Russia. The same men are also shown in photographs taken in Ukraine. Their appearance in both photographs was presented as evidence of Russian involvement in eastern Ukraine. The packet was later provided by American officials to The New York Times, which included that description of the group photograph in an article and caption that was published on Monday.

According to the NYT: Jen Psaki, a State Department spokeswoman, acknowledged that the assertion that the photograph in the American briefing materials had been taken in Russia was incorrect.

Update 23/04/2014

The BBC have taken the route of rewriting their article and giving it a new headline. “Ukraine: Photos ‘show Russian troops’ in east” has now become “Ukraine crisis: What the ‘Russian soldier’ photos say” (Same URL)

Update 24/04/2014

Time magazine’s reporter Simon Shuster has tracked down the bearded man in the photos above, His name is apparently Alexander Mozhaev – he is a Cossack and a member of the “rapid reaction force of the local separatist militia.”

14 responses to Evidence of undercover Russian troops in Ukraine debunked

  1. 

    Also, the red bearded special forces soldier pictured in the photo captioned “Georgia 2008″ has been identified as the intelligence chief of the Chechen special battalion “Vostok”, named Hamzat Gajrbekov (Хамзат Гайрбеков).
    The Vostok battalion, part of the 42nd Russian army, was dissolved in 2008, partly because of repeated allegation of war crimes committed in the Chechen and Russo-Georgian conflicts.
    Hamzat was presumably abducted and killed in September 2011.
    A higher resolution version of the picture confirms visually that the allegation of the two bearded man being one and the same is totally fabricated:

    http://club.foto.ru/gallery/photos/1220701/?&author_id=46372&series_id=33536&sort=date&next_photo_id=1221984&prev_photo_id=1219118

    Another picture of the bearded Cossak in Sloviansk :

    Additional Sources:
    Vostok battalion

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Battalions_Vostok_and_Zapad

    http://www.agentura.ru/english/timeline/2005/borozdinovskaya/

    Hamzat Gajrbekov

    http://www.trud.ru/article/26-09-2008/133720_vostok_v_zone_porazhenija/print/

    http://www.kavkazcenter.com/tur/content/2011/09/08/7069.shtml

    http://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=201122&cid=1 (Video)

    With all this information being accessible on the internet, why did the State Department still corroborate their allegations with this fake evidence?
    It’s kind of a “Curveball” moment…

  2. 

    Guy with reddish beard is a Chechen killed in Chechnia in Sept. 2011. His name is Hamzat Gajrbekov.
    See http://img3.picload.org/image/llrlrll/propaganda-debunked.jpg

  3. 

    Well, there are only two possibilities to explain this. Either they are totally dumb, or they just believe that we are totally dumb to swallow any brazen lie which they would try to feed us with. I am not sure which one is worse. But for some time I am already taking as a lie everything any US State Department official would say including “good morning”, “the” or “a”, until the opposite is proven beyond any reasonable doubt.

  4. 

    Russia had to insert “special forces” to “create conditions” for a referendum. So you say. Why do you need killers to have a vote?

  5. 

    I’m surprised you’ve left this story up – its a bit embarrassing now for the author isn’t it?

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. Ukraine: Die Mainstreammedien als Erfüllungsgehilfen auf dem Weg zum Dritten Weltkrieg | www.konjunktion.info - April 27, 2014

    […] ist fast perfekt Photos Link Masked Men in East Ukraine to Russia NYT Retracts Russian-Photo Scoop Evidence of undercover Russian troops in Ukraine debunked Peinliche Panne bei Übung: Polizisten beschädigen eigenen Wasserwerfer mit Eiern Wasserwerfer von […]

  2. MH flight shot down over Ukraine - Page 4 - July 18, 2014

    […] actual part of current Russian special forces detachments,then what does that prove?? Plus this: http://humanrightsinvestigations.org…aine-debunked/ Plus this is what the BBC said: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-27104904 No doubt […]

  3. Kiev’s Fake Picture Scam | SLAVYANGRAD.org - August 8, 2014

    […] involvement in Ukraine. It inspired massive headlines in all the western media, and was only exposed as a fake when the central picture turned out to be stolen from the Instagram account of photographer Maxim […]

  4. Kiev’s Fake Picture Scam | Your Newsline Independent Reporting From Around The World - August 8, 2014

    […] inspired massive headlines in all the western media, and was only exposed as a fake when the central picture turned out to be stolen from the Instagram account of photographer Maxim […]

  5. Kiev’s Fake Picture Scam | TRUTH - August 14, 2014

    […] inspired massive headlines in all the western media, and was only exposed as a fake when the central picture turned out to be stolen from the Instagram account of photographer Maxim […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s