In Ukraine, the lunatics have taken over the asylum

August 7, 2014 — 13 Comments

As the regime in Kiev sends tanks and militia in to clear the remnants of the Maidan; as the Maidan pleads that their government is trying to destroy them and as the head of NATO goes to Kiev to offer support to a regime which is shelling the cities of Lugansk and Donetsk with Grad rockets, the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) have just issued the results of their “investigation” into the downing of MH17.

This is the official statement that has just issued on the SBU website claiming MH17 was downed by mistake – rebels had intended to down an Aeroflot flight from Moscow in order to justify an invasion, but there had been a mix-up of place names:

During the investigation of Malaysia Airlines Boeing-777 downing the law enforcement and intelligence bodies established that terrorists and militants have cynically planned the terrorist attack at Aeroflot civil aircraft, AFL-2074 Moscow-Larnaca, which was flying over the territory of Ukraine at that moment. Hereof informed the Head of the Security Service of Ukraine Mr. Valentyn Nalyvaichenko during the briefing today.

He underlined – the crime was planned as a ground for bringing of Russian troops into Ukraine, that is – CASUS BELLI for the Russian military invasion.

According to the official Ukrainian data, June 17, 2014, at the mentioned time two regular international flights were operating over the territory of Ukraine following the filed requests for aircraft clearance – MAS17 plane of the Malaysia Airlines and AFL-2074 one of Aeroflot.

The routes of the mentioned international flights were approaching the sky over Donetsk. At 16:09 in the area of Novomykolaivka town the routes of the mentioned flights crossed. It is worth noting that the flight specifications of the aircrafts were almost identical – the Malaysian aircraft flew at a height of 10,100 m at a speed 909 km/h, while the Russian one – at a height of 10,600 m at a speed 768 km/h.

At 16:20 from the area of ‘Pervomaiske’ village, north-east from Donetsk, near the town of Torez, terrorists shot down the Malaysian jet, which then crashed near Grabove, Donetsk region.

According to the intercepted and published data about the ‘Buk” missile system, the terrorists had received an order to place the system near ‘Pervomaiskoe’ village, V. Nalyvaichenko mentioned. The namesake village is located about 20 km to the north-east from Donetsk.

The terrorists (most of them are not locals, but the Russian mercenaries) misrecognized the namesake villages and moved the other way, the SSU Head said. The odd route of the ‘Buk’ missile system on the territory of Ukraine proves that fact. The system crossed the Russia-Ukraine border in Luhansk region, then was deployed westward to Donetsk and moved back to the border between Donetsk and Luhansk regions afterwards.

By setting up the ‘Buk’ missile system in ‘Pervomaiske’ village located to the west from Donetsk and taking into consideration the military specifications of the weapon, the terrorists could have shot down the Russian civilian jetliner with its further crashing on the Ukrainian territory controlled by the ATO forces.

In that case Russia would receive an opportunity to accuse the Ukrainian authorities of downing the Russian plane, assaulting the Russian citizens and would use this irresistible proof for its invasion into Ukraine.

Russian side would need a compelling argument for such a step, for example accusation of the Ukrainian government in mass murder of the Russian citizens.

“A peculiar cynicism appears in the fact that the terrorist act was planned just against the peaceful, innocent Russian citizens, who were flying with their children on vacation”, – V. Nalyvaichenko, stressed.

Intelligence data proved that on July 18 the militants have already waited for the introduction of Russian Armed forces into the territory of Ukraine. The Russian side had been giving grounding for such developments for the several previous days. The Russian Mass Media had massively published information about the alleged shelling of the RF territory from the Ukrainian side.
SSU Press-Center

[End of quote]

When it comes to assessing the SBU version of events here are a couple of initial observations.

1) The person writing this scenario appears to be confused, writing in one sentence “At 16:20 from the area of ‘Pervomaiske’ village, north-east from Donetsk, near the town of Torez, terrorists shot down the Malaysian jet, which then crashed near Grabove, Donetsk region.”

Torez is east of Donetsk.

2) The two villages referred to are Pervomais’kyi and Pervomais’ke – they are spelt differently:

Pervomais’kyi / ПЕРВОМАЙСЬКИЙ is 86km due east of Donetsk, just south of Snizhne.

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Pervomais%27kyi,+Donetsk+Oblast,+Ukraine/@47.9884398,38.7500414,12z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x40e1ace3f082008f:0xbbc7246c9443d634

Pervomais’ke / Первомайське is 20km north of Donetsk on the M04

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Pervomais%27ke,+Donetsk+Oblast,+Ukraine/@48.0880172,37.5890651,13z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x40e09d1c112928bb:0x37aad30489aa9276

3) In the “intercepted and published data” mentioned the instructions are to meet by the Motel near Hornostaevka which is at the beginning of the H21 (ie on the way to Pervomais’kyi).

(2:58 on this audio tape published by the SBU):

4) The only mention of “Pervomaiskoe” on the tape is in a conversation between “Khmuryi” and an “unknown” militant in which he is told “You come there, there is Pervomiskoe nearby, look at the map.” (at 3:29).

5) In the alleged conversation between (at 2.35) “Kumuryi” says to “Buryat”: “And now have you brought it on a vehicle? Don’t put in anywhere… I’ll tell now where it should go, it will go together with “Vostok” tanks.” and there the audio clip ends. So the SBU needs to at least provide the whole of this conversation.

6) The fact an Aeroflot plane was within range of a village sounding similar North West of Donetsk, and that the two plane’s flight paths crossed at some stage is extremely weak evidence on which to build a conspiracy theory.

7) Why would Pervomais’ke be chosen for a false flag attack when it is well within rebel territory?

8) How credible is it that anyone would commit a false flag attack of this scale, of such incredible importance, using operatives who were so incompetent and plans which were so unclear that the operatives managed to base themselves over 100km away from where they were supposed to be and shoot down the wrong plane?

9) That this conspiracy theory should be presented as fact, without any further supporting evidence, defies belief.

Why is this theory, with so little evidence, being presented as fact?

1) There may be some major problems with the “accidental rebel shoot-down” theory.
2) The Ukrainians are keen to present the rebels as the evil culprit and this theory does that.
3) It seems highly likely that Andriy Parubiy, the previous head of the Ukrainian Security Serices, resigned the day of this release as he objected to its publication.
4) There may be a psychological process going on here, such as projection.

The theory and its presentation without any real supporting evidence certainly seems to reflect a high degree of paranoia or simply delusion, and it is very worrying that a medium-sized country can fall into the hands of people with this kind of mentality.

It is even more worrying that the political leaders of Europe are turning a blind eye to the insane and hysterical Russophobia which has infected Ukraine and threatens to engulf the continent.

(updated 8/8/2014. 9/8/2014)

13 responses to In Ukraine, the lunatics have taken over the asylum

  1. 

    The strangest thing is that no western MSM has touched this story, though it’s been 10 hrs since it appeared on the official SBU site and was reported by pravda.com.ua and then repeated throughout the ua and ru sites. RT has not mentioned it either. All sides to the conflict appear in deep shock over this.

    lol the lunatics have taken over the asylum

    • 

      I’m still in shock to be honest! A lot of the media has been trying to present the Ukrainian authorities as reasonable, rational actors. Difficult to see how they can report this and maintain that fiction.

  2. 

    Wow, how many reasons does Russia need to just invade already? Back in February, Kiev says (in part) Russia sent snipers to the Maidan, hoping to bring “Nazis” to power so they could use that as an excuse to invade. Now they’re down to blowing up airliners in further desperate attempts.
    Against the place name mix-up, they’re mixed up. It was Snizhne everyone (including me) points to. not Pervomaiske. And why did they accidentally pick a town (Snizhne) primed to accept a Buk launcher by the apartment bombing there two days earlier? Russia hit that on purpose, they say, then took advantage of it on accident? Given no maps, coords, or precise launch spot, just go to the town starting with P… and I guess this episode of the Russian sub-human intelligence cartoon show is based on a fevered dream after eating too much cheese .

  3. 
    Christopher Brooks August 8, 2014 at 01:20

    This new story contradicts the “audio intercept” narrative.

    Is Kiev admitting it was a fraud?

    This where’s Wally Buk meme ignores the complicated realities of
    the BUK technology and assisting equipment requirements and
    the problem of the missing BUK plume evidence.

    • 

      CB, the plume’s not missing. It’s in a photo, placed on a line that includes a line of scorched fields and odd new tracks on the same line to hit the airliner as it was hit – head-on. See here. (not to start an off-topic argument – except maybe there?)

      • 
        Christopher Brooks August 8, 2014 at 20:18

        causticlogic, the plume photo you point to is the only one I have seen anywhere and it
        is sourced from the Ukraine SBU. This source has supplied some tricky material and claims. Is there any other record of a BUK plume.

  4. 

    Andriy Parubiy has resigned on the same day this came out (http://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/30934.html).

    Both him and Nalyvaichenko have been accused by the former head of SBU of having coordinated the Maidan sniper attacks (http://acloserlookonsyria.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Talk:Ukraine_2014#Mercenaries_commanded_by_Andriy_Parubiy).

    The rats are cornered.

    • 

      Yes, I was just in the process of adding this to the text above when you made this comment. It seems likely he disagreed with the publication. He must have been overruled by Porochenko. Probably Parubiy knows more about the actual facts than Porochenko.

    • 

      “Earlier it was reported that the resignation letter was written July 25. According to the mass media, the reason for this decision was the disagreement between the President and the Secretary of the Security Council. It specifically relates to the field of the information policy. At the same time it was reported that some of the candidates for this position were Valentin Nalyvaichenko and Yuriy Stets.” http://joinfo.ua/politic/980157_The-Secretary-of-RNBO-Andriy-Parubiy-resigns.html

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. MH17 Investigation – What we know « Human rights investigations - August 8, 2014

    […] operation by a group of pro-Kiev operatives. 5) The Ukrainian government position that it was a Russian false flag operation is not credible. 6) We know one BUK on a trailer travelled from Donetsk to Snizhne on the day of […]

  2. Ukraine Officials: Rebels Were Trying To Down A Russian Passenger Plane, To Create Pretext For Invading Ukraine - Авиационный Портал - August 14, 2014

    […] writers, myself included, have had to deliberate long and hard whether to write about, as one pro-Russian site scoffs, the “remarkable claim” of “the lunatics who have taken over the asylum.” No one […]

  3. MH17 – Lying for Justice | - November 22, 2015

    […] of the allegations to the Dutch-led team leading the investigation into the crash. [1] See also [2] & […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s